37 [CLOSED] Cozy upper east cafe where the fare is “good except for the muffins”. Critics say “stick to the coffee” because the namesake “tastes like ass.” [SK] 1638 3rd Ave. 212/987-2404 Baked GoodsCarnegie HillClosed FacebookTwitterPinterestCopy LinkEmail You may also like The Big Easy August 4, 2001 Nightingale Bar February 26, 2000 Toasties East at 48 February 15, 2010 Global 33 February 26, 2000 Cafe Spice (Union Square) February 26, 2000 Hallo Berlin June 9, 2002 Food Merchants (Murray Hill) September 26, 2005 Popeyes Chicken & Biscuits (Times Square) October 14, 2002 Hourglass Tavern August 6, 2003 Subway (Carnegie Hill) June 9, 2002