75 [CLOSED] Cozy upper east cafe where the fare is “good except for the muffins”. Critics say “stick to the coffee” because the namesake “tastes like ass.” [SK] 1638 3rd Ave. 212/987-2404 Baked GoodsCarnegie HillClosed FacebookTwitterPinterestCopy LinkThreadsBlueskyEmail You may also like Connolly’s Pub & Restaurant – 5th Ave. February 12, 2021 Fez February 26, 2000 Atrium Deli February 26, 2000 Tovar’s Restaurant August 6, 2003 McHale’s April 1, 2003 Broadway Diner February 26, 2000 Yoshinoya February 10, 2003 San Marzano Brick Oven Pizzeria August 29, 2010 Sugar Deli Food Center May 13, 2009 Nightingale Bar February 26, 2000