Mr. Hipster
  • TV
    • TVTelevision ReviewsGood / Bad Commercial
      Television Reviews
      The Beast in Me
      Television Reviews
      Platonic: Season 2
      Television Reviews
      Wayward
      Television Reviews
      The Lowdown
      Television Reviews
      American Primeval
      Television Reviews
      Task
      Television Reviews
      The Beast in Me
      Television Reviews
      Platonic: Season 2
      Television Reviews
      Wayward
      Television Reviews
      The Lowdown
      Television Reviews
      American Primeval
      Television Reviews
      Task
      Good / Bad Commercial
      The More You Know: How to Pronounce “Comfortable”…
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Mattress Firm “Jumbled Up”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Good Commercial: JUBLIA “Dad’s Toenails”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: J.G. Wentworth “Living at Home”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Apple iPhone 12 “Fumble”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Good Commercial: GEICO “Tag Team Helps With Dessert”
  • Music
    • MusicAlbum ReviewsThe Music ListConcert Reviews
      Album Reviews
      SNOWMEN: A Kick to the Face
      Album Reviews
      Snocaps: Snocaps
      Album Reviews
      Greg Freeman: Burnover
      Album Reviews
      Lock Up: Something Bitchin’ This Way Comes
      Album Reviews
      Aesop Rock: Black Hole Superette
      Album Reviews
      Morphine: Cure for Pain
      Album Reviews
      SNOWMEN: A Kick to the Face
      Album Reviews
      Snocaps: Snocaps
      Album Reviews
      Greg Freeman: Burnover
      Album Reviews
      Lock Up: Something Bitchin’ This Way Comes
      Album Reviews
      Aesop Rock: Black Hole Superette
      Album Reviews
      Morphine: Cure for Pain
      The Music List
      The Grunge Diaspora
      The Music List
      I Still Own a Lot of CDs
      The Music List
      Top Listens 2023
      The Music List
      In Defense of: OMC’s “How Bizarre”
      The Music List
      Top 25 Influential Rock Albums
      The Music List
      In Defense Of: Ruben Studdard’s “Sorry 2004”
      Concert Reviews
      Vampire Weekend @ The Wellmont Theater
      Concert Reviews
      Sea.Hear.Now Festival 2025
      Concert Reviews
      The Get Up Kids @ Starland Ballroom
      Concert Reviews
      The Dirty Nil @ White Eagle Hall
      Concert Reviews
      The Beths @ White Eagle Hall
      Concert Reviews
      Pearl Jam @ MSG
  • Movies
    • Movie Reviews
      I Saw the TV Glow
      Movie Reviews
      Drop
      Movie Reviews
      No One Will Save You
      Movie Reviews
      Black Bag
      Movie Reviews
      The Phoenician Scheme
      Movie Reviews
      A Complete Unknown
      Movie Reviews
      Mickey 17
  • Books
    • Book Reviews
      Dinner at the Center of the Earth
      Book Reviews
      North Woods
      Book Reviews
      Trust
      Book Reviews
      Razorblade Tears
      Book Reviews
      The Plot
      Book Reviews
      Maximum Bob
      Book Reviews
      The Sympathizer
  • Podcasts
    • Podcast Reviews
      Hyperfixed
      Podcast Reviews
      The Wedding Scammer
      Podcast Reviews
      Search Engine
      Podcast Reviews
      Hysterical
      Podcast Reviews
      60 Songs That Explain the ’90s
      Podcast Reviews
      Otherworld
      Podcast Reviews
      Behind the Bastards
  • Booze & Grub
    • Booze & Grub ReviewsBooze & Grub: NYCBooze & Grub: NJThe NYC Booze & Grub GraveyardThe NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Uncle Momo – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Brick & Dough
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      MM by Morimoto
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Jalwa: Modern Indian Dining
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Slicehaus Pizzeria
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Maker Pizza
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Slicehaus Pizzeria
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Brooklyn Steel
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      McDonald’s (West Village)
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      CAVA – 350 Hudson
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Westville Hudson
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Five Guys – Midtown West
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Uncle Momo – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Brick & Dough
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      MM by Morimoto
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Jalwa: Modern Indian Dining
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Maker Pizza
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Laboratorio Kitchen
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard: Gone Before Their…
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      The Press Box Restaurant & Pub
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Natureworks – Midtown
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      The National Bar & Dining Rooms
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Hillstone – Midtown
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Connolly’s Pub & Restaurant – 5th Ave.
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard: Gone Before Their…
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Scala del Nonna
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Diesel & Duke – Montclair
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Maple Leaf Diner
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Ruthie’s Bar-B-Q & Pizza
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Junior’s Cheesesteaks & Shakes
  • Randomness
    • Travel Reviews
    • Video Game Reviews
    • Product Reviews
    • Odd Finds
    • Diary
Booze & Grub ReviewsBooze & Grub Reviews: NYCThe NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard

Red Stone Pizzeria Cafe

by mr. hipster May 17, 2011
May 17, 2011
129
Red Stone Pizzeria Cafe
Neighborhood: Midtown East
Cuisine: Pizza
[CLOSED]

I can’t even tell you how many chicken rolls I’ve had over the course of my lifetime, but suffice it to say it’s a shit-ton. Though never in my long history with the roll have I experienced one so corpulent, so full of matter as the one at Red Stone. The thing was like the size of a Nerf football and as heavy as a shot put and had more cheese than an entire fleet of pizzas. After pulling out two pounds of the gooey stuff, I was left with something relatively tasty, but still overwhelmingly monstrous. Now I’m not gonna complain about getting more food for my money, but at some point one crosses over into absurdity. The restaurant itself has a nice, clean, modern design and approach going on in the world of mostly pizza, but also soups and sandwiches like many who deal in midtown lunch. It certainly beats the atmosphere of the greasy windowed, green plywood boothed, neon signed pizza joints around the city. They’re like the Target of pizza places. It’s the same shit you’d find at any other place, but they put it in a nice package and sell it. My only complaint, aside from the stomach pains, was that the little sauce containers are a little too small, especially for that behemoth roll, and not at all convenient for dipping. [MF]


422 Madison Ave.
212/421-1223


ClosedMidtown EastPizza
FacebookTwitterPinterestCopy LinkEmail

You may also like

OBAO Noodles & BBQ – Midtown East

March 18, 2021

El Rio Grande

February 26, 2000

Jimmy’s No. 43

February 15, 2011

Tapeo29

August 5, 2010

Max Restaurant – East Village

May 25, 2008

Ranch 1 (Times Square)

October 4, 2000

Tres Carnes (Midtown East)

April 26, 2015

Caffè Buon Gusto (Sutton)

August 4, 2001

Isadora’s Cafe

July 5, 2010

Fresh & Co. (Midtown East)

December 3, 2010

NYC Neighborhoods

Astoria Beekman Bowery Bronx Brooklyn Brooklyn Heights Carnegie Hill Chelsea Chinatown DUMBO East Village East Williamsburg Financial District Flatiron Fort Greene Gramercy Grand Central Area Grand Central Terminal Greenpoint Greenwich Village Hell's Kitchen Hudson Square Kips Bay Koreatown Lenox Hill Lincoln Square Little Italy Lower East Side Meatpacking District Midtown East Midtown West MSG Area Murray Hill NoHo NoLita Queens Rockefeller Center Seaport SoHo Spanish Harlem Sutton Theater District Times Square TriBeCa Turtle Bay Union Square Area Upper East Side Upper West Side West Village Williamsburg Yorkville

NYC Cuisine

Afghan American Argentinian Asian Fusion Austrian Bagels Baked Goods Barbecue Bar Food Belgian Brazilian Brunch Burger Joint Caribbean Cheese Chinese Continental Cuban Cupcakes Deli Diner English Fast Food French Fried Chicken German Greek Halal Hot Dogs Indian Indonesian Israeli Italian Japanese Korean Kosher Latin American Lebanese Lunch Smorgasbord Malaysian Mediterranean Mexican Middle Eastern Moroccan New American Peruvian Pizza Pub Grub Puerto Rican Ramen Rotisserie Russian Salad Salad Bar Place Sandwich Shop Scottish Seafood Soup Southern Southwestern Spanish Steakhouse Street Meat Sushi Tapas Tex-Mex Thai Theme Restaurant Turkish Vegetarian Vietnamese Wings

NYC Bar / Venue Types

After Work Ale House Arcade Bar Beautiful People Beer Hall Beer Joint Belgian Bar Bowling Brewpub Caribbean Drinks Casual Lounge Champagne Lounge Cigar Bar Classic Bar Cocktails Coffeehouse Coffeehouse Bar College/Frat Bar Dancing Dive Bar Funky Lounge Gastropub Gay Hookah Bar Hotel Bar Irish Pub Jazz Club Karaoke Live Music Margaritas Neighborhood Bar Plastic Beer Signs Pool Hall Really Old Redneck Bar Retro Lounge Rock 'n' Roll Bar Sleazoid Snoozefest Sports Bar Strip Club Suit-Guy Bar Swanky Tasting Classes Theme Bar Underage Joint Wine Bar Yuppie

The Latest

The Beast in Me
December 3, 2025
Uncle Momo – Montclair
December 1, 2025
Platonic: Season 2
November 26, 2025

Random Posts

Battlestar Galactica: Seasons 1 – 4
January 13, 2012
Enzo Pizzeria and Restaurant
July 3, 2024
Capitale
August 6, 2003

More Random Posts

Rocky Balboa
July 4, 2008
Patsy’s Italian Restaurant
February 7, 2005
Fury
September 1, 2001
Kane Brewing Company Overhead Imperial Indie Pale Kane Brewing Company Overhead Imperial Indie Pale Ale #kane #kanebrewing #kanebrewingcompany #imperialipa #ipa
Shannon Rose Lager by Ghost Hawk #ghosthawk #ghost Shannon Rose Lager by Ghost Hawk #ghosthawk #ghosthawkbrewingco #lager
Rogue Ales Morimoto Soba Ale #rogueales #morimoto Rogue Ales Morimoto Soba Ale #rogueales #morimoto
Community Beer Works Let’s Go Pils #communitybeerw Community Beer Works Let’s Go Pils #communitybeerworks #pilsner
2019 Alberto Orte Calma Crianza Tempranillo Rioja 2019 Alberto Orte Calma Crianza Tempranillo Rioja #albertoorte #crianza #tempranillo #rioja
2019 Cantina del Nebbiolo Barbaresco #cantinadelne 2019 Cantina del Nebbiolo Barbaresco #cantinadelnebbiolo #barbaresco
  Contact Mr. Hipster
Instagram Facebook Youtube
  • TV
    • TVTelevision ReviewsGood / Bad Commercial
      Television Reviews
      The Beast in Me
      Television Reviews
      Platonic: Season 2
      Television Reviews
      Wayward
      Television Reviews
      The Lowdown
      Television Reviews
      American Primeval
      Television Reviews
      Task
      Television Reviews
      The Beast in Me
      Television Reviews
      Platonic: Season 2
      Television Reviews
      Wayward
      Television Reviews
      The Lowdown
      Television Reviews
      American Primeval
      Television Reviews
      Task
      Good / Bad Commercial
      The More You Know: How to Pronounce “Comfortable”…
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Mattress Firm “Jumbled Up”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Good Commercial: JUBLIA “Dad’s Toenails”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: J.G. Wentworth “Living at Home”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Apple iPhone 12 “Fumble”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Good Commercial: GEICO “Tag Team Helps With Dessert”
  • Music
    • MusicAlbum ReviewsThe Music ListConcert Reviews
      Album Reviews
      SNOWMEN: A Kick to the Face
      Album Reviews
      Snocaps: Snocaps
      Album Reviews
      Greg Freeman: Burnover
      Album Reviews
      Lock Up: Something Bitchin’ This Way Comes
      Album Reviews
      Aesop Rock: Black Hole Superette
      Album Reviews
      Morphine: Cure for Pain
      Album Reviews
      SNOWMEN: A Kick to the Face
      Album Reviews
      Snocaps: Snocaps
      Album Reviews
      Greg Freeman: Burnover
      Album Reviews
      Lock Up: Something Bitchin’ This Way Comes
      Album Reviews
      Aesop Rock: Black Hole Superette
      Album Reviews
      Morphine: Cure for Pain
      The Music List
      The Grunge Diaspora
      The Music List
      I Still Own a Lot of CDs
      The Music List
      Top Listens 2023
      The Music List
      In Defense of: OMC’s “How Bizarre”
      The Music List
      Top 25 Influential Rock Albums
      The Music List
      In Defense Of: Ruben Studdard’s “Sorry 2004”
      Concert Reviews
      Vampire Weekend @ The Wellmont Theater
      Concert Reviews
      Sea.Hear.Now Festival 2025
      Concert Reviews
      The Get Up Kids @ Starland Ballroom
      Concert Reviews
      The Dirty Nil @ White Eagle Hall
      Concert Reviews
      The Beths @ White Eagle Hall
      Concert Reviews
      Pearl Jam @ MSG
  • Movies
    • Movie Reviews
      I Saw the TV Glow
      Movie Reviews
      Drop
      Movie Reviews
      No One Will Save You
      Movie Reviews
      Black Bag
      Movie Reviews
      The Phoenician Scheme
      Movie Reviews
      A Complete Unknown
      Movie Reviews
      Mickey 17
  • Books
    • Book Reviews
      Dinner at the Center of the Earth
      Book Reviews
      North Woods
      Book Reviews
      Trust
      Book Reviews
      Razorblade Tears
      Book Reviews
      The Plot
      Book Reviews
      Maximum Bob
      Book Reviews
      The Sympathizer
  • Podcasts
    • Podcast Reviews
      Hyperfixed
      Podcast Reviews
      The Wedding Scammer
      Podcast Reviews
      Search Engine
      Podcast Reviews
      Hysterical
      Podcast Reviews
      60 Songs That Explain the ’90s
      Podcast Reviews
      Otherworld
      Podcast Reviews
      Behind the Bastards
  • Booze & Grub
    • Booze & Grub ReviewsBooze & Grub: NYCBooze & Grub: NJThe NYC Booze & Grub GraveyardThe NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Uncle Momo – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Brick & Dough
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      MM by Morimoto
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Jalwa: Modern Indian Dining
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Slicehaus Pizzeria
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Maker Pizza
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Slicehaus Pizzeria
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Brooklyn Steel
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      McDonald’s (West Village)
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      CAVA – 350 Hudson
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Westville Hudson
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Five Guys – Midtown West
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Uncle Momo – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Brick & Dough
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      MM by Morimoto
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Jalwa: Modern Indian Dining
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Maker Pizza
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Laboratorio Kitchen
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard: Gone Before Their…
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      The Press Box Restaurant & Pub
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Natureworks – Midtown
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      The National Bar & Dining Rooms
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Hillstone – Midtown
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Connolly’s Pub & Restaurant – 5th Ave.
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard: Gone Before Their…
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Scala del Nonna
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Diesel & Duke – Montclair
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Maple Leaf Diner
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Ruthie’s Bar-B-Q & Pizza
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Junior’s Cheesesteaks & Shakes
  • Randomness
    • Travel Reviews
    • Video Game Reviews
    • Product Reviews
    • Odd Finds
    • Diary

©2025 MR. HIPSTER DOT COM ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Mr. Hipster
  • TV
    • TVTelevision ReviewsGood / Bad Commercial
      Television Reviews
      The Beast in Me
      Television Reviews
      Platonic: Season 2
      Television Reviews
      Wayward
      Television Reviews
      The Lowdown
      Television Reviews
      American Primeval
      Television Reviews
      Task
      Television Reviews
      The Beast in Me
      Television Reviews
      Platonic: Season 2
      Television Reviews
      Wayward
      Television Reviews
      The Lowdown
      Television Reviews
      American Primeval
      Television Reviews
      Task
      Good / Bad Commercial
      The More You Know: How to Pronounce “Comfortable”…
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Mattress Firm “Jumbled Up”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Good Commercial: JUBLIA “Dad’s Toenails”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: J.G. Wentworth “Living at Home”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Apple iPhone 12 “Fumble”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Good Commercial: GEICO “Tag Team Helps With Dessert”
  • Music
    • MusicAlbum ReviewsThe Music ListConcert Reviews
      Album Reviews
      SNOWMEN: A Kick to the Face
      Album Reviews
      Snocaps: Snocaps
      Album Reviews
      Greg Freeman: Burnover
      Album Reviews
      Lock Up: Something Bitchin’ This Way Comes
      Album Reviews
      Aesop Rock: Black Hole Superette
      Album Reviews
      Morphine: Cure for Pain
      Album Reviews
      SNOWMEN: A Kick to the Face
      Album Reviews
      Snocaps: Snocaps
      Album Reviews
      Greg Freeman: Burnover
      Album Reviews
      Lock Up: Something Bitchin’ This Way Comes
      Album Reviews
      Aesop Rock: Black Hole Superette
      Album Reviews
      Morphine: Cure for Pain
      The Music List
      The Grunge Diaspora
      The Music List
      I Still Own a Lot of CDs
      The Music List
      Top Listens 2023
      The Music List
      In Defense of: OMC’s “How Bizarre”
      The Music List
      Top 25 Influential Rock Albums
      The Music List
      In Defense Of: Ruben Studdard’s “Sorry 2004”
      Concert Reviews
      Vampire Weekend @ The Wellmont Theater
      Concert Reviews
      Sea.Hear.Now Festival 2025
      Concert Reviews
      The Get Up Kids @ Starland Ballroom
      Concert Reviews
      The Dirty Nil @ White Eagle Hall
      Concert Reviews
      The Beths @ White Eagle Hall
      Concert Reviews
      Pearl Jam @ MSG
  • Movies
    • Movie Reviews
      I Saw the TV Glow
      Movie Reviews
      Drop
      Movie Reviews
      No One Will Save You
      Movie Reviews
      Black Bag
      Movie Reviews
      The Phoenician Scheme
      Movie Reviews
      A Complete Unknown
      Movie Reviews
      Mickey 17
  • Books
    • Book Reviews
      Dinner at the Center of the Earth
      Book Reviews
      North Woods
      Book Reviews
      Trust
      Book Reviews
      Razorblade Tears
      Book Reviews
      The Plot
      Book Reviews
      Maximum Bob
      Book Reviews
      The Sympathizer
  • Podcasts
    • Podcast Reviews
      Hyperfixed
      Podcast Reviews
      The Wedding Scammer
      Podcast Reviews
      Search Engine
      Podcast Reviews
      Hysterical
      Podcast Reviews
      60 Songs That Explain the ’90s
      Podcast Reviews
      Otherworld
      Podcast Reviews
      Behind the Bastards
  • Booze & Grub
    • Booze & Grub ReviewsBooze & Grub: NYCBooze & Grub: NJThe NYC Booze & Grub GraveyardThe NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Uncle Momo – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Brick & Dough
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      MM by Morimoto
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Jalwa: Modern Indian Dining
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Slicehaus Pizzeria
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Maker Pizza
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Slicehaus Pizzeria
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Brooklyn Steel
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      McDonald’s (West Village)
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      CAVA – 350 Hudson
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Westville Hudson
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Five Guys – Midtown West
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Uncle Momo – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Brick & Dough
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      MM by Morimoto
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Jalwa: Modern Indian Dining
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Maker Pizza
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Laboratorio Kitchen
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard: Gone Before Their…
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      The Press Box Restaurant & Pub
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Natureworks – Midtown
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      The National Bar & Dining Rooms
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Hillstone – Midtown
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Connolly’s Pub & Restaurant – 5th Ave.
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard: Gone Before Their…
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Scala del Nonna
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Diesel & Duke – Montclair
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Maple Leaf Diner
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Ruthie’s Bar-B-Q & Pizza
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Junior’s Cheesesteaks & Shakes
  • Randomness
    • Travel Reviews
    • Video Game Reviews
    • Product Reviews
    • Odd Finds
    • Diary