10 [CLOSED] Cozy upper east cafe where the fare is “good except for the muffins”. Critics say “stick to the coffee” because the namesake “tastes like ass.” [SK] 1638 3rd Ave. 212/987-2404 Baked GoodsCarnegie HillClosed FacebookTwitterPinterestCopy LinkEmail You may also like Sambuca August 4, 2001 Penang (Upper East Side) October 14, 2002 Dempsey’s Pub April 4, 2007 Pret a Manger (Rockefeller Center) January 14, 2006 The Flying Puck December 2, 2010 Devin Tavern December 13, 2008 Caffè Buon Gusto (Chelsea) February 5, 2004 Craftsteak May 4, 2007 Big Sur February 26, 2000 Fashion Forty June 20, 2006