Mr. Hipster
  • TV
    • TVTelevision ReviewsGood / Bad Commercial
      Television Reviews
      Maximum Pleasure Guaranteed: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      The Agency: Season 2
      Television Reviews
      The Bear: Season 5
      Television Reviews
      Widow’s Bay: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      Margo’s Got Money Troubles: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      Running Wilde
      Television Reviews
      Maximum Pleasure Guaranteed: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      The Agency: Season 2
      Television Reviews
      The Bear: Season 5
      Television Reviews
      Widow’s Bay: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      Margo’s Got Money Troubles: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      Running Wilde
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Afrin “Congestion Takeover”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      The More You Know: How to Pronounce “Comfortable”…
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Mattress Firm “Jumbled Up”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Good Commercial: JUBLIA “Dad’s Toenails”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: J.G. Wentworth “Living at Home”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Apple iPhone 12 “Fumble”
  • Music
    • MusicAlbum ReviewsThe Music ListConcert Reviews
      Album Reviews
      Quicksand: Bring On the Psychics
      Album Reviews
      mildred: Fenceline
      Album Reviews
      Blackpool Lights: This Town’s Disaster
      Album Reviews
      Death Cab for Cutie: I Built You A…
      Album Reviews
      State Lines: Hoffman Manor
      Album Reviews
      Thomas Dollbaum: Birds of Paradise
      Album Reviews
      Quicksand: Bring On the Psychics
      Album Reviews
      mildred: Fenceline
      Album Reviews
      Blackpool Lights: This Town’s Disaster
      Album Reviews
      Death Cab for Cutie: I Built You A…
      Album Reviews
      State Lines: Hoffman Manor
      Album Reviews
      Thomas Dollbaum: Birds of Paradise
      The Music List
      The Grunge Diaspora
      The Music List
      I Still Own a Lot of CDs
      The Music List
      Top Listens 2023
      The Music List
      In Defense of: OMC’s “How Bizarre”
      The Music List
      Top 25 Influential Rock Albums
      The Music List
      In Defense Of: Ruben Studdard’s “Sorry 2004”
      Concert Reviews
      Vampire Weekend @ The Wellmont Theater
      Concert Reviews
      Sea.Hear.Now Festival 2025
      Concert Reviews
      The Get Up Kids @ Starland Ballroom
      Concert Reviews
      The Dirty Nil @ White Eagle Hall
      Concert Reviews
      The Beths @ White Eagle Hall
      Concert Reviews
      Pearl Jam @ MSG
  • Movies
    • Movie Reviews
      Good Luck, Have Fun, Don’t Die
      Movie Reviews
      After Yang
      Movie Reviews
      Midnight Run
      Movie Reviews
      Send Help
      Movie Reviews
      Dead Again
      Movie Reviews
      Every Movie I’ve Ever Seen…
      Movie Reviews
      Shallow Grave
  • Books
    • Book Reviews
      Home Land
      Book Reviews
      A Little Blood and Dancing
      Book Reviews
      Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow
      Book Reviews
      Everybody Knows
      Book Reviews
      The Future
      Book Reviews
      Dinner at the Center of the Earth
      Book Reviews
      North Woods
  • Podcasts
    • Podcast Reviews
      Hyperfixed
      Podcast Reviews
      The Wedding Scammer
      Podcast Reviews
      Search Engine
      Podcast Reviews
      Hysterical
      Podcast Reviews
      60 Songs That Explain the ’90s
      Podcast Reviews
      Otherworld
      Podcast Reviews
      Behind the Bastards
  • Booze & Grub
    • Booze & Grub ReviewsBooze & Grub: NYCBooze & Grub: NJThe NYC Booze & Grub GraveyardThe NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Traditas Pizza – NoMad
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      The Highlawn
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Playa Bowls – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      The Moon Korean BBQ & Hot Pot
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Dutch Fred’s
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Brooklyn Music Kitchen
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Traditas Pizza – NoMad
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Dutch Fred’s
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Brooklyn Music Kitchen
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Pig ‘N’ Whistle Public House
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Bocca di Bacco – Chelsea
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Back Bar
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      The Highlawn
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Playa Bowls – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      The Moon Korean BBQ & Hot Pot
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      La Rocca Osteria
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Domino’s – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      State Street Grill
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Two Boots – East Village
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard: Gone Before Their…
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      The Press Box Restaurant & Pub
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Natureworks – Midtown
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      The National Bar & Dining Rooms
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Hillstone – Midtown
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Uncle Momo – Montclair
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Tastee Platters – Montclair
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Oso Felipe
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard: Gone Before Their…
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Scala del Nonna
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Diesel & Duke – Montclair
  • Randomness
    • Travel Reviews
    • Video Game Reviews
    • Product Reviews
    • Odd Finds
    • Diary
Booze & Grub ReviewsBooze & Grub Reviews: NYCThe NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard

Brother Jimmy’s BBQ — Murray Hill

by mr. hipster November 8, 2010
November 8, 2010
219
Brother Jimmy's
Neighborhood: Murray Hill
Cuisine: Barbecue
Bar Type: Redneck Bar
[CLOSED]

It seems there is one of these Bro Jimmy’s joints opening every other week. I used to live a couple hundred feet from The Bait Shack back in the day and the smoky waves of barbecue smoke would waft into my open window on warm summer nights and tempt me with ribs I don’t even eat. Flash forward twelve or thirteen years and I find myself standing in one of the now seven locations amongst mere babes in an underground den of undergraduate beer swillers trying to watch my alma mater try to sink a bucket against some stupid Midwestern university full of mouth breathers and hayseeds. I don’t recall if they won, but I do remember having a really annoying conversation with some kid from said alma mater who thought he was the new white Jay-Z and was gonna take the dorm circuit by storm. I made the mistake of telling him where I worked (despite it being totally useless for him to be talking to me) and he pulled out some homemade card and threatened to send me the mixtape of the rapper he produced in an off-campus apartment. Awkward social interaction aside, this place is kind of built like a redneck’s dream of what a set of what a respectable redneck bar would look like. A little too clean to be authentic, this particular outpost boasts the half-finished look of your step-mother’s Southern basement, complete with exposed studs and beams, piled moonshine barrels and requisite Christmas lights. We spent the majority of our time in about ten square feet of space being squeezed by packs of children and a kids a little bit older than children, but the cavernous space seems to go on and on and, like the dream of a Southern EPCOT, features different themed rooms ranging from beat up license plates to NASCAR shit. I had forgotten how young this neighborhood is, and it seemed as if every kid in the ‘hood was out in force. Budweiser and babies; just what everyone needs. [MF]


181 Lexington Ave. (bet. 31st and 32nd St.)
212/779-7427


BarbecueBrother Jimmy'sClosedMurray HillRedneck Bar
FacebookTwitterPinterestCopy LinkEmail

You may also like

Nice Guy Eddie’s

August 4, 2001

AZ

June 10, 2004

HB Burger

August 16, 2010

Wonder Foods

September 26, 2005

Digby’s Cafe

May 15, 2006

Picholine

April 8, 2008

Brother Jimmy’s BBQ – The Bait Shack

February 26, 2000

goodburger (Midtown East)

September 18, 2009

Soba Nippon

May 4, 2007

Cedar Tavern

April 9, 2005

The Latest

Home Land
August 4, 2026
Maximum Pleasure Guaranteed: Season 1
July 31, 2026
Traditas Pizza – NoMad
July 29, 2026

Random Posts

The Buzzing
August 15, 2003
Caught Stealing
December 21, 2025
May December
January 14, 2024

More Random Posts

John Dies at the End
July 11, 2012
Kool Keith: Black Elvis/Lost In Space
August 10, 2002
Zodiac
December 29, 2008
West Kill Brewing Perch Golden Ale #westkillbrewin West Kill Brewing Perch Golden Ale #westkillbrewing #goldenale
Trillium Brewing Company Party Pump #trillium #tri Trillium Brewing Company Party Pump #trillium #trilliumbrewing #goldenale
Foam Brewers Tranquil Pils German Pilsner #foambre Foam Brewers Tranquil Pils German Pilsner #foambrewers #germanpilsner #pilsner
Industrial Arts Brewing Company Metric Pils #indus Industrial Arts Brewing Company Metric Pils #industrialarts #industrialartsbrewing #pilsner
Stone Brewing Dayfest IPA #stonebrewing #ipa Stone Brewing Dayfest IPA #stonebrewing #ipa
2023 Pillar & Post Anderson Valley Pinot Noir #pil 2023 Pillar & Post Anderson Valley Pinot Noir #pillarandpost #pinotnoir
  Contact Mr. Hipster
Instagram Facebook Youtube
  • TV
    • TVTelevision ReviewsGood / Bad Commercial
      Television Reviews
      Maximum Pleasure Guaranteed: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      The Agency: Season 2
      Television Reviews
      The Bear: Season 5
      Television Reviews
      Widow’s Bay: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      Margo’s Got Money Troubles: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      Running Wilde
      Television Reviews
      Maximum Pleasure Guaranteed: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      The Agency: Season 2
      Television Reviews
      The Bear: Season 5
      Television Reviews
      Widow’s Bay: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      Margo’s Got Money Troubles: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      Running Wilde
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Afrin “Congestion Takeover”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      The More You Know: How to Pronounce “Comfortable”…
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Mattress Firm “Jumbled Up”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Good Commercial: JUBLIA “Dad’s Toenails”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: J.G. Wentworth “Living at Home”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Apple iPhone 12 “Fumble”
  • Music
    • MusicAlbum ReviewsThe Music ListConcert Reviews
      Album Reviews
      Quicksand: Bring On the Psychics
      Album Reviews
      mildred: Fenceline
      Album Reviews
      Blackpool Lights: This Town’s Disaster
      Album Reviews
      Death Cab for Cutie: I Built You A…
      Album Reviews
      State Lines: Hoffman Manor
      Album Reviews
      Thomas Dollbaum: Birds of Paradise
      Album Reviews
      Quicksand: Bring On the Psychics
      Album Reviews
      mildred: Fenceline
      Album Reviews
      Blackpool Lights: This Town’s Disaster
      Album Reviews
      Death Cab for Cutie: I Built You A…
      Album Reviews
      State Lines: Hoffman Manor
      Album Reviews
      Thomas Dollbaum: Birds of Paradise
      The Music List
      The Grunge Diaspora
      The Music List
      I Still Own a Lot of CDs
      The Music List
      Top Listens 2023
      The Music List
      In Defense of: OMC’s “How Bizarre”
      The Music List
      Top 25 Influential Rock Albums
      The Music List
      In Defense Of: Ruben Studdard’s “Sorry 2004”
      Concert Reviews
      Vampire Weekend @ The Wellmont Theater
      Concert Reviews
      Sea.Hear.Now Festival 2025
      Concert Reviews
      The Get Up Kids @ Starland Ballroom
      Concert Reviews
      The Dirty Nil @ White Eagle Hall
      Concert Reviews
      The Beths @ White Eagle Hall
      Concert Reviews
      Pearl Jam @ MSG
  • Movies
    • Movie Reviews
      Good Luck, Have Fun, Don’t Die
      Movie Reviews
      After Yang
      Movie Reviews
      Midnight Run
      Movie Reviews
      Send Help
      Movie Reviews
      Dead Again
      Movie Reviews
      Every Movie I’ve Ever Seen…
      Movie Reviews
      Shallow Grave
  • Books
    • Book Reviews
      Home Land
      Book Reviews
      A Little Blood and Dancing
      Book Reviews
      Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow
      Book Reviews
      Everybody Knows
      Book Reviews
      The Future
      Book Reviews
      Dinner at the Center of the Earth
      Book Reviews
      North Woods
  • Podcasts
    • Podcast Reviews
      Hyperfixed
      Podcast Reviews
      The Wedding Scammer
      Podcast Reviews
      Search Engine
      Podcast Reviews
      Hysterical
      Podcast Reviews
      60 Songs That Explain the ’90s
      Podcast Reviews
      Otherworld
      Podcast Reviews
      Behind the Bastards
  • Booze & Grub
    • Booze & Grub ReviewsBooze & Grub: NYCBooze & Grub: NJThe NYC Booze & Grub GraveyardThe NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Traditas Pizza – NoMad
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      The Highlawn
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Playa Bowls – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      The Moon Korean BBQ & Hot Pot
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Dutch Fred’s
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Brooklyn Music Kitchen
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Traditas Pizza – NoMad
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Dutch Fred’s
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Brooklyn Music Kitchen
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Pig ‘N’ Whistle Public House
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Bocca di Bacco – Chelsea
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Back Bar
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      The Highlawn
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Playa Bowls – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      The Moon Korean BBQ & Hot Pot
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      La Rocca Osteria
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Domino’s – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      State Street Grill
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Two Boots – East Village
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard: Gone Before Their…
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      The Press Box Restaurant & Pub
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Natureworks – Midtown
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      The National Bar & Dining Rooms
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Hillstone – Midtown
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Uncle Momo – Montclair
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Tastee Platters – Montclair
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Oso Felipe
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard: Gone Before Their…
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Scala del Nonna
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Diesel & Duke – Montclair
  • Randomness
    • Travel Reviews
    • Video Game Reviews
    • Product Reviews
    • Odd Finds
    • Diary

©2026 MR. HIPSTER DOT COM ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Mr. Hipster
  • TV
    • TVTelevision ReviewsGood / Bad Commercial
      Television Reviews
      Maximum Pleasure Guaranteed: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      The Agency: Season 2
      Television Reviews
      The Bear: Season 5
      Television Reviews
      Widow’s Bay: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      Margo’s Got Money Troubles: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      Running Wilde
      Television Reviews
      Maximum Pleasure Guaranteed: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      The Agency: Season 2
      Television Reviews
      The Bear: Season 5
      Television Reviews
      Widow’s Bay: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      Margo’s Got Money Troubles: Season 1
      Television Reviews
      Running Wilde
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Afrin “Congestion Takeover”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      The More You Know: How to Pronounce “Comfortable”…
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Mattress Firm “Jumbled Up”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Good Commercial: JUBLIA “Dad’s Toenails”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: J.G. Wentworth “Living at Home”
      Good / Bad Commercial
      Bad Commercial: Apple iPhone 12 “Fumble”
  • Music
    • MusicAlbum ReviewsThe Music ListConcert Reviews
      Album Reviews
      Quicksand: Bring On the Psychics
      Album Reviews
      mildred: Fenceline
      Album Reviews
      Blackpool Lights: This Town’s Disaster
      Album Reviews
      Death Cab for Cutie: I Built You A…
      Album Reviews
      State Lines: Hoffman Manor
      Album Reviews
      Thomas Dollbaum: Birds of Paradise
      Album Reviews
      Quicksand: Bring On the Psychics
      Album Reviews
      mildred: Fenceline
      Album Reviews
      Blackpool Lights: This Town’s Disaster
      Album Reviews
      Death Cab for Cutie: I Built You A…
      Album Reviews
      State Lines: Hoffman Manor
      Album Reviews
      Thomas Dollbaum: Birds of Paradise
      The Music List
      The Grunge Diaspora
      The Music List
      I Still Own a Lot of CDs
      The Music List
      Top Listens 2023
      The Music List
      In Defense of: OMC’s “How Bizarre”
      The Music List
      Top 25 Influential Rock Albums
      The Music List
      In Defense Of: Ruben Studdard’s “Sorry 2004”
      Concert Reviews
      Vampire Weekend @ The Wellmont Theater
      Concert Reviews
      Sea.Hear.Now Festival 2025
      Concert Reviews
      The Get Up Kids @ Starland Ballroom
      Concert Reviews
      The Dirty Nil @ White Eagle Hall
      Concert Reviews
      The Beths @ White Eagle Hall
      Concert Reviews
      Pearl Jam @ MSG
  • Movies
    • Movie Reviews
      Good Luck, Have Fun, Don’t Die
      Movie Reviews
      After Yang
      Movie Reviews
      Midnight Run
      Movie Reviews
      Send Help
      Movie Reviews
      Dead Again
      Movie Reviews
      Every Movie I’ve Ever Seen…
      Movie Reviews
      Shallow Grave
  • Books
    • Book Reviews
      Home Land
      Book Reviews
      A Little Blood and Dancing
      Book Reviews
      Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow
      Book Reviews
      Everybody Knows
      Book Reviews
      The Future
      Book Reviews
      Dinner at the Center of the Earth
      Book Reviews
      North Woods
  • Podcasts
    • Podcast Reviews
      Hyperfixed
      Podcast Reviews
      The Wedding Scammer
      Podcast Reviews
      Search Engine
      Podcast Reviews
      Hysterical
      Podcast Reviews
      60 Songs That Explain the ’90s
      Podcast Reviews
      Otherworld
      Podcast Reviews
      Behind the Bastards
  • Booze & Grub
    • Booze & Grub ReviewsBooze & Grub: NYCBooze & Grub: NJThe NYC Booze & Grub GraveyardThe NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Traditas Pizza – NoMad
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      The Highlawn
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Playa Bowls – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      The Moon Korean BBQ & Hot Pot
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Dutch Fred’s
      Booze & Grub Reviews
      Brooklyn Music Kitchen
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Traditas Pizza – NoMad
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Dutch Fred’s
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Brooklyn Music Kitchen
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Pig ‘N’ Whistle Public House
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Bocca di Bacco – Chelsea
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NYC
      Back Bar
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      The Highlawn
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Playa Bowls – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      The Moon Korean BBQ & Hot Pot
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      La Rocca Osteria
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      Domino’s – Montclair
      Booze & Grub Reviews: NJ
      State Street Grill
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Two Boots – East Village
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard: Gone Before Their…
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      The Press Box Restaurant & Pub
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Natureworks – Midtown
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      The National Bar & Dining Rooms
      The NYC Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Hillstone – Midtown
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Uncle Momo – Montclair
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Tastee Platters – Montclair
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Oso Felipe
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard: Gone Before Their…
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Scala del Nonna
      The NJ Booze & Grub Graveyard
      Diesel & Duke – Montclair
  • Randomness
    • Travel Reviews
    • Video Game Reviews
    • Product Reviews
    • Odd Finds
    • Diary