[CLOSED] Became: Judge Crater’s is now: Biddy’s Pub
Critics describe it as a “hot smoky box not unlike being trapped on the surface of a cancerous lung.” But fans of the awkward space say “the jukebox spins great tunes and the old drunks are usually pretty harmless.” Most can’t make heads or tails of the shabby decor and ancient bartender who kindly offers patrons two year old pretzels from behind the bar. [MF]
301 E 91st St.
212/831-1788